Fictional Fighting at its Finest

Zorro vs. Indiana Jones

Tags: ,

Ground rules: Each are equipped with both a whip and a sword and are in their phyiscal prime. The arena is an old ghost town in Mexico.

Personal bias: I liked the Mask of Zorro quite a bit when it first came out, but I still love the Indiana Jones movies to this day. I even liked most the Crystal Skull, but the parts that I didn’t like make it a distant fourth compared to the origial trilogy. That seems to be a theme with Lucas movies…

Fight! Indy spots a black cape dart behind a building through the tumbleweeds. He figures that his opponent will try to get the jump on him. He also wishes this contest involved guns.

Zorro flicks his whip to the rooftop of the old saloon and uses it to pull himself up, securing the higher ground. He slowly moves to the edge of the buiding to peer over where he last saw Indiana Jones. Indy is still standing in place and is looking right back at Zorro’s “hiding” spot.

“Shall we settle this like civilized men?” askes Zorro.

“You’re the one on the roof,” replies Indiana.

Zorro slides down the old bar’s auning to face his opponent and raises his sword. Indy takes the bull whip from his belt and unleashes it upon his foe. The tip of the whip cracks just short of Zorro’s sword hand. “Fencing isn’t my strong suit,” says Indy.

Zorro darts ahead, flailing his cape as projection from the sting of the whip and lunges forward the point of his blade. Indy narrowly escapes with a cut across his abdomin. Jones catches Zorros attacking arm in his whip and swings him to the ground. The sword is flung out of reach. Zorro then rolls out of the way of the next attack while tosses the dry earth in Indy’s eyes. Jones is angered by the tatic and manages to tackle Zorro without the use of his vision.

Both brawlers wrestle it out, now weaponless. Indy kicks Zorro off his person and away from the sword, allowing himself to claim the weapon. Zorro quickly regains his footing only to be knocked unconsious by the blunt handle of the sword.

Results: Indiana Jones proves the winner of fortune and glory. Well, at least glory.

  • HellsColdDay
    Re: Nathan. Well I do love that scene, but that is why I didn't equip either of them with a gun in the "Ground rules."

    Re: Daniel. Not sure if Zorro is better with a whip...but you may have won me over with the swordmanship issue. I'll say one more comment from someone from your camp and I'll change the ending.
  • Nathan Story
    If you noticed in Raiders of the Lost Ark, Indy uses guns to beat swordsmen. One shot and it'd be over.
  • Daniel Montgomery
    I must disagree with this one. Indiana would perhaps be better at running through a gauntlet of traps and decyphering puzzles and codes, but Zorro would never lose a sword fight to him. He's the Robin Hood of fencing style swordsmanship. Would Robin Hood lose an archery contest to any non-mutant mortal? Nope. Would Zorro lose to any non-mutant mortal in a Rapier/ whip battle? Nope. He is certainly superior in whip skills as well. Jones is good, but his main strength is quick thinking, not outright battle. Perhaps if there were an airplane propeller backing up, Jones could lure him into it but that's the only way he could win: luring him into a trap. Straight up man to man, whip and sword, nothing else- not a chance.
blog comments powered by Disqus